Mrs. Roy E. Tomlinson, Ross, Ohio

Montclair Art Museum, New Jersey, gift from above, 1961

Sale, Christie’s, New York, New York, June 16–17, 2009, lot 121, from above

Thomas Colville Fine Art, Guilford, Connecticut



The American Painting Collection of the Montclair Art Museum (Montclair, NJ: Montclair Art Museum, 1977), 65, 216, no. 155.


Important Painter of the Hudson River School

By Elliot Roberts

Known for his lush autumnal and pastoral landscapes, William Hart is a celebrated artist of the Hudson River School. Contemporaries praised him for his ability to balance a strict interpretation of nature with sentimental undertones. His paintings can be found at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, National Academy of Design, and the New-York Historical Society.

I. Biography
II. Chronology
III. Collections
IV. Exhibitions
V. Memberships
VI. Notes
VII. Suggested Resources

I. Biography

Born in 1823 in Paisley, Scotland, William Hart emigrated with his parents to the United States at the age of nine and settled in Albany, New York. It was here that Hart first began his artistic training when he was placed under the tutelage of Messrs, Eaton & Gilbert, the prestigious coach-makers from Troy, New York. During this time, Hart learned how to decorate coach panels, covering them with either landscapes or figurative compositions. At the age of seventeen, he was eagerly contemplating an artist’s profession. Consequently, he left the mechanical trade of coach-making and began expanding his artistic pursuits to more refined endeavors.[1]

Hart followed coach-making with decorating window shades and later developed an interest in portraiture. Around 1840, he established his first formal studio in his father’s woodshed in Troy. There, he created many likenesses of individuals, affording him a nominal income. Once, he remarked that he felt prouder over his first fee of five dollars for painting a head then for the larger sums he would command later in his career. Nevertheless, his wages from portraits during this early period proved insufficient. Thus, he expanded into landscape painting, allowing him to barter his works or sell them for modest prices.[2]

In 1842, Hart moved to Michigan in an attempt to further his success; portraiture remained his primary means of support. Unfortunately, his experiences in the West were disappointing. Hart spent three years living a rough existence until he finally returned to Albany in 1845. Upon his return, he fully devoted himself to the art of landscape painting. Despite his failing health, he worked diligently to perfect his skill until 1849 when he traveled abroad to his native land of Scotland. This trip was made possible through the generosity of his patron and advisor, Dr. Ormsby of Albany. For three years, he studied in the open-air, creating brilliant sketches of the Scottish Highlands and the surrounding British Isles.[3]

Returning to Albany once more in 1852, Hart enjoyed improved health and was reinvigorated with purpose. The following year, he moved to New York and opened a studio, promoting himself as a specialist in landscape painting. Hart became a regular contributor to the National Academy of Design. His works received a great deal of attention from artists and connoisseurs alike, all of whom praised him for his fresh, self-taught style. In 1855, he was designated as an associate of the National Academy of Design; three years later he was elected to Academician. In 1865, he was unanimously chosen to be the first president of the Brooklyn Academy of Design. It was during his tenure there that he delivered his famous lecture The Field and Easel, which emphasized the distinguishing principles of landscape art in America.[4] Hart argued that landscape painters should express the “look of the place” being depicted.[5] Critics during the 1870s noted his sensitive balance between capturing a strict “real” interpretation of nature and that of a more “ideal” sentimental tone. For instance, in 1869, Putnam Magazine noted that Hart brought back “exquisite studies” of the surrounding Tappan Zee area that were both well executed and full of artistry.[6]

In the 1870s and ’80s, Hart continued to receive much public attention. Earl Shinn noted in an 1876 review of Hart’s work his distinct use of color, stating:

He loves to struggle with one of the most difficult feats of landscape-painting, the dazzling tints of our forests in autumn. His pictures of those mounds of leafy bloom which the Adirondacks yield in November are veritable bouquets of florid color. [7]

Consequently, Hart’s landscapes graced both auction houses and many of the largest collections during the latter half of the 19th century. Furthermore, Hart’s demand during this period is evidenced in the many engravings of his paintings for gift books and art journals, including 13 works which were featured in Picturesque America, the most popular of such publications of the 1870s.[8]

II. Chronology

1823 Born in Paisley, Scotland on March 31, 1823.
1831 Moved to America and settled in Albany, New York with his family.
1840 Moved to Troy, New York and opened his first studio.
1842 Moved to Michigan.
1845 Returned to Albany fully committed to the art of landscape painting.
1849 Traveled abroad to his native land of Scotland thanks to the generosity of his patron, Dr. Ormsby.
1852 Returned to Albany after studying in Scotland for three years.
1854 Moved to New York and opened a studio promoting himself as a landscape painter.
1855 Designated as an associate of the National Academy of Design.
1858 Elected to full membership in the National Academy of Design.
1865 Became the first president of the Brooklyn Academy of Design.
1866 Co-founded the American Watercolor Society.
1867 Gave his famous lecture The Field and Easel.
1870–72 President of the American Watercolor Society.
1894 Died in Mt. Vernon, New York on June 17, 1894.

III. Collections

Albany Institute of History and Art, Albany, New York
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York
National Academy of Design, New York
National Museum of American, Washington, D.C.
New-York Historical Society, New York
Vassar College, Poughkeepsie, New York

IV. Exhibitions

1848, 1853–65, 1867–71, 1874–89, 1891–94 National Academy of Design, New York
1854–59, 1862, 1866–1868 Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia
1861–64, 1866–78, 1882–1883 Brooklyn Art Association, Brooklyn, New York
Also exhibited at the Boston Athenaeum.

V. Memberships

President, Brooklyn Academy of Design (1865)
Associate Member, National Academy of Design (1855)
Full-Member, National Academy of Design (1858)
Founder and President, American Watercolor Society (1870–1872)

VI. Notes

1. “Masters of Art and Literature: Eighth Article, William Hart,” in Cosmopolitan Art Journal 2, no. 4 (1858): 183.
2. Ibid.
3. “American Painters – William Hart,” Art Journal I, no. 8 (1875): 246.
4. Ibid., 246–7.
5. Barbara Novak, Nature and Culture: American Landscape and Painting, 1825-1875 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1995), 134.
6. Mark Sullivan, James M. and William Hart: American Landscape Painters (Philiadelphia: John F. Warren, 1983), 6–8.
7. Ibid., 6.
8. Ibid., 8.

VII. Suggested Resources

“American Painters – William Hart,” Art Journal I, no. 8, (1875): 246–7.
Ferber, Linda S. The Hudson River School: Nature and the American Vision (New York: Skira Rizzoli International Publications, Inc., 2009).
“Masters of Art and Literature: Eighth Article, William Hart,” Cosmopolitan Art Journal 2, no. 4 (1858): 183–4.
Novak, Barbara. Nature and Culture: American Landscape and Painting, 1825–1875 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1995).
Sears, Clara Endicott. Highlights Among the Hudson River Artists (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1947).
Sullivan, Mark. James M. and William Hart: American Landscape Painters (Philiadelphia: John F. Warren, 1983).

William Hart (1823–1894)
Along the Winding Way, 1864
Oil on canvas
39½ x 54¼ inches
Signed and dated lower left: WM. HART 64
+ Enlarged View
Email or share this painting
Contact Us About This Painting

Name (required)

Business Name




Address (cont.)




Questions or Comments

Enter above 4 characters (required):

Having problems?
Please email us: